The battleground of mid-size pickup trucks has never been more competitive, with automakers vying to clinch the top spot with their distinct fusion of manageable size, potency, adaptability, and utility. In the quest to discover the ultimate victor among the fiercest contenders, we've assembled four of the most popular models in the crowded mid-size pickup truck segment; the Ford Ranger, the New Chevy Colorado, the Nissan Frontier, and the Toyota Tacoma.
Prepare for an adrenaline-fueled comparison as we delve into key factors such as their engines, fuel economy, torque, overall capabilities, and interiors to determine which of these mid-size pickup rises above the rest.
2023 Ford Ranger: $28,585 - $39,945
The Ford Ranger hasn't changed much for the 2023 model year. Under its hood lies an impressive 2.3-liter EcoBoost four-cylinder engine capable of producing 270 horsepower with 310 pound-feet of torque, while its available 10-speed automatic transmission ensures smooth shifts over any terrain!
With the power of an EcoBoost engine and EPA-estimated fuel efficiency at 21 MPG city and 26 MPG highway, for the 2WD models with that figure dropping to 19 combined MPG on the rugged 4WD model! And when it comes to tackling any adventure outdoors, this truck won't let you down. It also boasts a best-in-class payload capacity of 1,860 pounds with a maximum towing capability of up to 7,500 pounds.
The Ford Ranger offers two distinct models, the SuperCrew and SuperCab. With four full-size doors and seating for up to five people in the former or two smaller half-doors allowing room for four passengers in the latter - everyone's needs can be met! Inside you'll find an interior design made with a combination of quality materials and some dull plastic pieces.
Both vehicles offer comfortable cabins fitted with simple controls, so riders stay connected through SYNC 3 infotainment touchscreen display featuring Apple CarPlay & Android Auto integration. Experience style combined with function and impressive tech capabilities - making the Ranger a formidable force in this clash of automotive titans. The real downside to the overall Ranger experience are its dated styling and cabin when compared to the competition.
2023 Chevy Colorado: $29,200 - $46,800
The all-new redesigned 2023 Colorado is a remarkable pickup truck that is sure to catch the attention of truck enthusiasts. Its powerful engine, available in different trims, is a turbocharged 2.7-liter inline-four engine paired with an eight-speed automatic transmission for seamless driving. The base WT and LT models have a 237 horsepower and 259 pound-feet of torque, outperforming the Toyota Tacoma's base four-cylinder engine.
The Z71 and Trail Boss models have a more formidable powerplant with 310 horsepower and 390 pound-feet of torque, while the range-topping ZR2 employs the same engine as Chevy's full-size Silverado 1500, delivering an impressive 430 foot-pounds of torque. The Desert Boss package also adds a segment exclusive underbody camera for when you're out rock crawling.
Buy beyond its off-road hardarew, the Colorado is also a proper work truck with powerful engines that can tow up to 7,700 pounds, making it the leader in its class. Even the entry-level engine can tow 3500 pounds while achieving an impressive EPA-estimated 20 MPG in the city and 25 MPG on the highway.
Regarding exceptional comfort and spaciousness, the Colorado's cabin stands out with an abundance of front headroom and generous legroom, ensuring a pleasant journey for both the driver and passengers. The seating is designed with comfort, and most trims even offer power-adjustable and heated front seats for added luxury.
The Colorado's infotainment system also comes equipped with Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and Bluetooth streaming capabilities, along with an 8.0-inch screen on most trims, with 11.3-inch touchscreen on top trims making Colorado an optimal choice for those who prioritize comfort and technology from their mid-size pcikups. With such an impressive range of options and features tailored to suit various needs, it's no wonder the New Chevy Colorado has set new standards in the world of pickup trucks.
2023 Nissan Frontier: $30,490 - $39,120
As a truck that received a redesign just last year, not much has changed on the rugged 2023 Nissan Frontier. It asserts its dominance in the class by boasting a 3.8-liter V-6 engine that generates a striking 310 horsepower and 281 pound-feet of torque. The engine, paired with a nine-speed automatic transmission, has been meticulously engineered to provide smooth and responsive performance, so you can easily conquer any terrain.
The V-6 power will cost you at the pumps though, as the Frontier offers an EPA-estimated 18 MPG city and 24 MPG highway, for a 2WD model, making it one of the thirstiest models in the class. However, the Frontier remains a reliable companion by delivering a maximum payload capacity of 1,610 pounds and a towing capacity of 6,720 pounds, which is a figure that is slightly behind the competition.
With features such as an advanced 9.0-inch touchscreen infotainment system and wireless charging capabilities to make every journey effortless, along with Fender premium audio for crisp sound quality and Zero Gravity front seats that deliver comfort mile after mile - this off-road vehicle has been designed to elevate your experience wherever you go. The available leather upholstery adds an extra touch of sophistication that will leave lasting impressions.
2023 Toyota Tacoma: $28,580 - $49,890
The time-tested 2023 Toyota Tacoma presents potential buyers with two powerful engines: a 2.7-liter four-cylinder engine boasting 159 horsepower and 180 pound-feet of torque or a muscular 3.5-liter V-6 engine capable of producing an impressive 278 horsepower and 265 pound-feet of torque. Coupled with a smooth 6-speed automatic transmission, the Tacoma expertly merges power with efficiency.
Regarding fuel efficiency, the four-cylinder engine achieves an EPA-estimated 23 MPG on the highways and 20 MPG in the city. Known for its outstanding off-roading capabilities, the Tacoma shines when outfitted with the TRD Off-Road or TRD Pro packages. Designed to cater to work and leisure, this remarkable truck offers a maximum payload capacity of 1,685 pounds and an astonishing towing capacity of 6,800 pounds.
Inside the Tacoma, you'll find top-of-the-line features that put convenience and practicality in your hands. From a 7.0 or 8.0-inch touchscreen to an infotainment system syncing up with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto - all of this tech is designed for easy reach, so you can stay focused on whatever's ahead of the wheel!
The Tacoma promises a fusion of function and simplistic ingenuity, proving that practicality and durability need not come at the expense of modern conveniences. As capable as the Taco is off-the pavement, its on road manner's aren't the best, and the a cramped rear seat leaves a lot to be desired. It needs to be seen what Toyota does with the upcoming 2024 model.
Conclusion: A Winner Emerges
In this epic battle, as the dust settled, it became apparent that the all-new Chevy Colorado stood head and shoulders above its rivals, claiming the title of the best mid-size pickup available today. This victory can be attributed to Chevy's strategy of simplifying the Colorado lineup with a single powerplant with several trims, including some properly competent off-road trims in the ZR2 and Trail Boss.
Features like the available Desert Boss package also add a segment exclusive underbody camera for when you're out rock crawling. The massive 11-inch screen feels very untruck like and lends off crossover vibes. The Colorado's remarkable combination of comfort, spaciousness and a robust yet versatile engine for the money further cements its top-ranking position for now.
So if you're willing to look past the fact that the new Colorado is only available in a single bed / cab configuration and doesn't offer a hybrid or diesel, you'll find that it is a well-rounded and far more modern mid-size pickup as compared to the competition. Find out more about the 2023 Chevy Colorado in our exclusive first-drive review.